Internal Control · 2025
In this section8 topics
- Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System1 item
- Internal Control Deficiencies2 items
- Audit Committee & Auditor Observations2 items
- Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit2 items
- Related Party Transactions1 item
- Counterparties & Transactions3 items
- Policy & Future Trends3 items
Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System
Internal Control Framework Used
| Framework | Detail |
|---|---|
| The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) | The Board of Directors places importance on the internal control system. Therefore, an internal control system has been set up to cover finance, management, and efficient and effective operations in accordance with the relevant laws, rules and regulations. The Board also focuses on continuous improvement in order to comply with the guidelines of COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organization of Treadway Commission) to make internal control and risk management more complete and most effective for the Company's various operations. In addition, the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 2/2025, held on 26 February 2025, assessed the adequacy of the internal control system in accordance with the guidelines of the SEC which consists of internal control systems in 5 aspects: control environment, risk assessment, management operational control, information systems and communication and monitoring system. The Board of Directors agrees with the Audit Committee’s opinion that the Company's internal control system are sufficient, appropriate and found no significant flaws which can be summarized as follows: 1. Control Environment The control environment is an essential element of the Company's internal control system. Therefore, a good control environment has been established as follows:
2. Risk Assessment
3. Control the operations of the management
4. Information and communication
5. Monitoring Activities
6. Implementation of the risk management process
|
Internal Control Deficiencies
Introduction
The Company places importance on its internal control system. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to review and assess the internal control system and report its findings to the Board, in order to establish appropriate corporate governance guidelines and ensure that all aspects of internal control are adequate and suitable for the Company’s business operations. This includes operational efficiency, effective use of resources, safeguarding of assets, prevention or reduction of errors, control of potential damages, preparation of accurate and reliable financial reports, and compliance with applicable laws, regulations, and relevant business requirements.
In this regard, the Company has identified no material weaknesses in its internal control system.
Number of Deficiencies
| Metric | Current Year | Previous Year | Two Years Ago |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Audit Committee & Auditor Observations
Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's
No
Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control
No
Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
Head of Internal Audit
3159
Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit
The Audit Committee Meeting No. 3/2016, held on 15 August 2016, approved the appointment of Ms. Vacharavan Buranabul to act as the Head of the Internal Audit department and had an opinion that Ms. Vacharavan Buranabul is qualified to perform her duty in the position of Head of the Internal Audit department of the Company as she has a Bachelor of Business Administration degree from the University of Illinois Chicago, USA and has experience in accounting operations both in Thailand and the United States for a period of 28 years and has also attended training courses related to the practice of internal auditing from the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand (The Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand).
Profile of Head of Internal Audit appears in Attachment 3.
Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit
Requires Audit Committee Approval
Yes
Description
The appointment, removal, and transfer of the person holding the position of internal audit manager of the Company or any other unit responsible for internal audit must be approved by the Audit Committee.
Related Party Transactions
Has Related Party Transactions
Yes
Counterparties & Transactions
Monetary Unit
1
Counterparties with Potential Conflicts
| Name | Person / Juristic Person | Type of Business | Nature of Relationship | As of Date (YYYY-MM-DD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mr. Prabsharan Singh Thakral (“PT”) | Person |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mr. Manmohan Singh Thakral (“MT”) | Person |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mrs. Rasmi Thakral (“RT”) | Person |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mr. Utpalendu Gupta (“UG”) | Person |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| Mr. Richard Peter Neville (“RN”) | Person |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 | |
| B Asset Management Ltd. | Juristic Person | Management Consulting |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 |
| BL 4 Ltd. | Juristic Person | Property Developer |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 |
| B North 2 Ltd. | Juristic Person | Food and Beverage Business |
| 2025-12-31T00:00 |
Transactions by Counterparty
| Transactions |
|---|
| 6600000.0 · Necessity: 1. From 1 January 2023, MT’s consultancy fee is paid by Boutique International Holdings Ltd. (Mauritius) according to the Consultancy Agreement with Boutique International Holdings Ltd. MT receives remuneration only for his consultancy service of Baht 550,000 per month and neither receives any other forms of compensation nor director’s remuneration. 2. Responsibilities of MT include contacting and managing relationships with investors/buyers, advising the Chief Executive Officer and management, being a contact point with investors regarding funding, capital calling, sale of projects, giving the latest information to investors, business plan, risk management monitoring, signing documents with banks / financial institutions and important documents for BC and its subsidiaries. MT will act in accordance with the direction from the Company’s Board of Directors. 3. Since MT is a consultant under the agreement and also a director of the Company, the payment of consultancy fee to him is considered a related party transaction. 4. The NRC Meeting 2/2018, held on 15 June 2018, recommended the Board of Directors to approve the scope of responsibilities and consultancy fee of MT. · Description: Since 1 June 2018, Mr. Manmohan Singh Thakral (MT) has been a director (authorized director) and a consultant to the Company based on the Consultant Agreement. · As of yesteryear: 6600000.0 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee (paid by Boutique International Holdings Ltd. – BIH, a subsidiary of BC) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the consultant service is considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. MT has always been a good advisor to the Company and Chief Executive Officer and the consultancy fee rate takes into account the qualifications, experience and working hours of MT of which the basis is similar to hiring a third-party consultant with the same qualifications, expertise and working hours as MT. Thus, the remuneration for MT is deemed appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 6600000.0 |
| 196667.0 · Necessity: 1. Since 1 January 2016, UG had been a director (authorized director) and a consultant to the Company and received remuneration only for his consultancy service of Baht 50,000 per month and neither received any other forms of compensation nor director’s remuneration. 2. Since UG was a consultant under the agreement and also the Company’s director, the payment of consultancy fee to him was considered a related party transaction. 3. The NRC Meeting 2/2018, held on 15 June 2018, recommended the Board of Directors to approve the scope of responsibilities and consultancy fee of UG. · Description: 1. On 1 December 2015, UG entered into a Consulting Employment Agreement with the Company to provide consultancy service in various fields such as business, finance, loans, contracts, perform tasks as assigned and sign various documents as assigned by the Board of Directors. 2. UG resigned from his positions as a director and advisor of the Company, effective 29 April 2025. · As of yesteryear: 600000.0 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee (paid by BC) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the consultant service was considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. UG had always been a good advisor to the Company and the consultancy fee rate took into account the qualifications, experience and working hours of UG of which the basis was similar to hiring a third-party consultant with the same qualifications, expertise and working hours as UG. Thus, the remuneration for UG was deemed appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 600000.0 |
| 900000.0 · Necessity: 1. Starting 1 May 2018, RN receives remuneration only for his consultancy service of Baht 75,000 per month and neither receives any other forms of compensation nor director’s remuneration. 2. Since RN is a consultant under the agreement and also the Company’s director, the payment of consultancy fee to him is considered a related party transaction. 3. The NRC Meeting 2/2018, held on 15 June 2018, recommended the Board of Directors to approve the scope of responsibilities and consultancy fee of RN. · Description: On 26 April 2018, RN entered into a Consulting Employment Agreement with the Company to provide consultancy service in financial aspects such as providing strategic advice in dealing with investors investing in projects, giving opinions and advice on investment structuring, planning and strategies, giving opinions on financial reports, analyzing financial data from an investor's perspective, and to be a consultant to the Chief Financial Officer. · As of yesteryear: 900000.0 · Nature of transaction: Consulting fee (paid by BC) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the consultant service is considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. The consultancy fee rate takes into account the qualifications, experience and working hours of RN of which the basis is similar to hiring a third-party consultant with the same qualifications, expertise and working hours as RN. Thus, the remuneration for RN is deemed appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 900000.0 |
| 11645.0 · Necessity: This transaction is a normal operating expense and is considered a related party transaction as B Asset Management Ltd. and the Company share common directors, namely, PT and MT. · Description: 1. The Company provides Human Resource software called ByteHR to its subsidiaries, affiliates and related companies. The cost of using this software is charged at Baht 120 per person per month, which is the same rate as the Company charges its subsidiaries and affiliates. 2. This charge back has been effective since May 2022 onwards and is charged yearly. · As of yesteryear: 17045.0 · Nature of transaction: Service fee (Accrued income at the end of the period) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the charge back of actual expenses is a normal business transaction to properly and correctly allocate expense and is considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. In addition, the rate charged is the same as that of the Company’s subsidiaries and affiliates. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 10104.0 · Necessity: This transaction is a normal operating expense and is considered a related party transaction as BL4 and the Company share common directors, namely, PT and MT. · Description: 1. The Company provides Human Resource software called ByteHR to its subsidiaries, affiliates and related companies. The cost of using this software is charged at Baht 120 per person per month, which is the same rate as the Company charges its subsidiaries and affiliates. 2. This charge back has been effective since May 2022 onwards and is charged yearly. · As of yesteryear: 14904.0 · Nature of transaction: Service fee (Accrued income at the end of the period) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the charge back of actual expenses is a normal business transaction to properly and correctly allocate expense and is considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. In addition, the rate charged is the same as that of the Company’s subsidiaries and affiliates. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 41413.0 · Necessity: This transaction is a normal operating expense and is considered a related party transaction as B North 2 Ltd. and the Company share common directors, namely, PT and MT · Description: 1. The Company provides Human Resource software called ByteHR to its subsidiaries, affiliates and related companies. The cost of using this software is charged at Baht 120 per person per month, which is the same rate as the Company charges its subsidiaries and affiliates. 2. This recharge has been effective since 2022 onwards and is charged yearly. · As of yesteryear: 59893.0 · Nature of transaction: Service fee (Accrued income at the end of the period) · Audit committee opinion: The Audit Committee opined that the charge back of actual expenses is a normal business transaction to properly and correctly allocate expense and is considered necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. In addition, the rate charged is the same as that of the Company’s subsidiaries and affiliates. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
| 18723106.0 · Necessity: Since RT is a direct family member of PT and MT, the loan transaction from RT is considered a related party transaction categorized under receiving financial assistance with small transaction size under the management authority. · Description: 1. According to Loan Agreement dated 17 December 2025, RT provided a loan facility of up to Baht 20 million to BC for funding its working capital. The interest rate for loan is in the same range of interest rate announced by the Thai Commercial Banks. 2. The term of the loan is 1 year (extendable annually subject to review of interest rate and terms). · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Loan and accrued interest at the end of the period · Audit committee opinion: 1. The Audit Committee opined that the loan was necessary, reasonable and beneficial to the Company. 2. The Board of Directors’ Meeting No.12/2025, held on 17 December 2025, acknowledged the necessity of the loan. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 |
Policy & Future Trends
Introduction
The Board of Directors gives importance on compliance with the good corporate governance principles to prevent conflicts of interest. Therefore, the Board of Directors has counseled the Company to establish clear and transparent process for approving related party transactions and strict compliance with the principles, approaches and guidelines on disclosing related party transactions as required by laws or competent agencies. Most of the Company’s transactions with related parties occur in the normal course of business and, therefore, are likely to reoccur. The policy and tendency to conduct transactions with related parties followed the same patterns as observed in previous years, namely they were conducted on the arm’s length basis, or normal commercial terms, in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders.
Policy, Measures & Approval Process
In the case where a connected transaction or a transaction that may cause conflicts of interest is necessary for the utmost interest of the Company and in line with the abovementioned principle, the Company ensures strict compliance with the laws and regulations stipulated by the SEC, the Notifications of the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the SET relevant to connected transactions.
Transactions under general commercial conditions must adhere to principles approved by the Board, ensuring an arm's length basis and prioritizing the maximum benefit of the Company.
Transactions that deviate from general commercial conditions and could potentially lead to conflicts of interest necessitate review and endorsement by the Audit Committee before seeking approval from the Board and/or shareholders, depending on the transaction size. Information disclosure for such transactions is required in accordance with the stipulated regulations.
In addition, the Company requires that any interested persons or connected persons declare their vested interest or relationship in a transaction under consideration. Such persons are prohibited from participating in the consideration or granting approval for such transaction. It is also required to disclose such transaction in the 56-1 One Report.
Future Trends in Related Party Transactions
The Company expects that any future inter-company transactions or related party transactions, if any, will be undertaken as appropriate and in line with the growth of the business. In this regard, the Company will strictly comply with the applicable rules and regulations of the SEC and the SET, as well as the approval measures and procedures as described above.

